Can I negotiate my bill at HSHS St. Mary's Hospital Medical Center?

Yes. 93% of patients who negotiate succeed. Use real pricing data to compare your charges against Medicare benchmarks and generate a dispute letter.

Hospitals / WI

HSHS St. Mary's Hospital Medical Center Pricing Analysis

Q: How expensive is HSHS St. Mary's Hospital Medical Center?

HSHS St. Mary's Hospital Medical Center in , WI charges about 23x the federal benchmark — pricier than average. Fairness grade: B (Below average prices).

Source: Hospital MRF file & CMS Medicare PFS 2026

, WI

View on Google Maps ↗

Fairness Grade

Below average prices

Price Multiplier

23x

the federal fair-price benchmark

Procedures Priced

3,295

150 comparable to federal rates

What does this mean for your bill? This hospital charges about 23x the federal benchmark — pricier than average.For example, a procedure the government prices at $100 would cost about $2,300 at this hospital's list price. If you're uninsured or out-of-network, you may be able to negotiate down significantly.

Check a specific procedure price

Use our price checker to look up any of 7,700+ procedures and see what Medicare considers a fair price.

Price Checker

Biggest Overcharges at This Hospital

These are the procedures where HSHS St. Mary's Hospital Medical Center charges the most compared to the federal fair-price benchmark. “They Charge” is what appears on your bill. “Gov. Benchmark” is what the government determines the doctor's work is worth.

Note:This hospital's published data mainly includes major surgical procedures. These charges include the cost of implanted devices (like pacemakers or joint replacements) and facility fees — not just the surgeon's work. The government benchmark shown only reflects the surgeon's fee, so the difference looks larger than it is for these procedures.

Procedure	Code	They Charge	Gov. Benchmark	You Overpay
Osteochondral Knee Allograft	27415	$36,757	$1,259	+$35,498

About HSHS St. Mary's Hospital Medical Center

HSHS St. Mary's Hospital Medical Center in WI, WI charges about 23x the federal benchmark — pricier than average across 150 procedures we could compare. This data comes directly from the hospital's own published price file — they're required by federal law to share it.

What this means for your bill

If you're uninsured, out-of-network, or have a high-deductible plan, these prices directly affect what you pay. If you have in-network insurance, your insurer has likely negotiated much lower rates.

Can I negotiate?

Yes. Most hospitals will reduce bills when patients present evidence. Our bill review service compares your specific charges to fair-price benchmarks and generates a dispute letter you can send to the billing department.

← Back to all hospital rankings

Compare with other hospitals

See how HSHS St. Mary's Hospital Medical Center stacks up against other hospitals in the area.

View All Rankings